Welcome to Johnny's Real New York Pizza
Welcome to Johnny's Real New York Pizza, a gem tucked away in Irvine, California. This inviting pizzeria prides itself on delivering an authentic New York experience with its thin, crisp crust and flavorful toppings. Customers rave about the delightful pepperoni pizza, paired perfectly with a fresh Italian salad. The charming atmosphere evokes nostalgia, reminiscent of classic pizzerias, making every visit special. Whether you’re enjoying a slice with friends, indulging in garlic knots, or taking advantage of their happy hour, there’s something for everyone. Johnny's is not just a meal; it’s a culinary journey that brings the essence of New York right to your plate.
-
6721 Quail Hill Pkwy, Irvine, CA 92603, United States Hotline: +1 949-823-1900
If you're on the hunt for genuine New York-style pizza in Irvine, look no further than Johnny's Real New York Pizza. Tucked away at 6721 Quail Hill Pkwy, this charming pizzeria is redefining the pizza scene in California one slice at a time. With a menu that boasts an array of enticing options, you’re sure to find something that satisfies every craving.
On entering Johnny's, you’re instantly enveloped in the nostalgic charm reminiscent of classic New York pizza joints. The enticing aroma of fresh pizzas coming out of the oven fills the air, beckoning you to indulge. Customers rave about the thin, crispy crust that is characteristic of true New York-style pizzas. One patron, Braulio A., described the pizza as, “the kind of slice that brings you back to classic pizza spots from the past.” Such sentiments highlight not only the authenticity embedded in each bite but also the care that goes into crafting each pizza.
Many fans of Johnny's have noted the flavorful toppings and perfectly balanced sauce. Henry Koo, who ordered for his pregnant wife’s cravings, expressed joy in discovering a pizza that was “thin and delicious” without the excessive grease often found in standard takeout. He summed it up perfectly: “It doesn’t taste junky either, no guilt like some other pizzas.” This perspective reflects a broader appreciation for the quality of ingredients Johnny’s employs.
Another highlight of Johnny's is its diverse menu. From their fabulous pepperoni pizza to enticing Italian salads and big-portioned garlic knots, there's something for everyone. As Micaela Chavez noted, the pepperoni pizza paired delightfully with its crisp, fresh ingredients, making every bite an experience to remember.
The service at Johnny's also garners rave reviews, with many customers such as Jeff praising the friendly staff who ensure a welcoming atmosphere. Having dishes that are both affordable and downright delicious, customers looking for value can enjoy happy hour specials that add to the overall appeal, making it a go-to spot for catching up with friends over a game.
Whether you're a local or just passing through, Johnny's Real New York Pizza promises a slice of New York nostalgia that you’ll want to savor again and again. With its combination of high-quality ingredients, welcoming service, and the authentic vibe of New York pizza culture, it undoubtedly deserves a spot on your culinary map.
First TIME Trying This Pizza Place! Pregnant Wife Approved!!! Loved it. I ordered not knowing there were bad reviews. It was a delivery order. I got scared after reading the reviews and wanted to cancel but it was too late. But then the pizza arrived. And it was delicious. All my worries were for nothing! My pregnant wife was happy! (Was ordered for her cravings) But boy, I enjoyed them too! They are thinner, which we both like, and we loved the flavor! It’s not like gooey arcade pizza, but it’s just the perfect amount. Yeah, the pizza wasnt hot by the time it arrived but we live far away. I heated it up in the oven and it’s just amazing! It reminds me of the pizza I used to eat growing up. The place must have read all the bad reviews and actually tried to improve! Cudos to them. But who knows, maybe it is hit or miss, so if you get a bad pizza don’t blame me lol. I loved it personally. It doesn’t taste junky either, no guilt like some other pizzas haha. Not greasy either. 9.5/10 pizza for me. Just need to heat it up a little in the oven. like 5 minutes in a 350 degree oven should do the trick.
Great service and NY style menu. the pepperoni pizza and Italian salad was fabulous. Will be back for the Italian ice! Highly recommend when your craving Zaaa :)
My wife’s office recently tried out a local pizzeria, and she insisted I stop by for a New York-style slice. So, with some time to spare and an appetite to match, I decided to check it out. The moment I walked through the door, I could tell I was in for something special. The place is small but packed with charm—like stepping into a retro pizzeria from the past. The aroma of fresh pizza filled the air, instantly making me hungrier. Their menu was simple but full of tempting choices, and I ended up ordering two slices of their Meat Lovers pizza along with a cold Mexican Coke. Let me just say: the hype was completely justified. The crust was thin and crisp, the toppings were generous and flavorful, and everything was perfectly balanced—just how a true New York-style slice should be. That first bite confirmed what my wife had said: this place delivers. It’s not just good pizza; it’s the kind of slice that brings you back to classic pizza spots from the past. Safe to say, this has officially become my new go-to spot whenever I’m craving that authentic New York pizza experience.
Paco is very inviting friendly humble, great customer service. I only wish that they would evenly spread the cheese out.
This spot gets 5 stars from me simply because of the two guys that work the kitchen. My initial interaction with the cashier hit a snag, but the food was good and the guy from Honduras(or might have been Venezuelan. I can’t remember) in the back provided a very high level of customer service. Super polite, attentive and friendly!! He made the experience a 5 star experience. Now to the food...the food was great! Had a pepperoni personal pizza, a cheese personal pizza, and wings. The sign says something about the cheese pizza being the best, oh it really is . The wings and sauce were perfect. We will be back soon.
My friends and I ordered a few things and everything tasted soo good! We definitely will be returning.
Yummy cheesy pizza with crunchy crust and crispy pepperoni. We love to go here for happy hour for a reasonably priced glass of red wine or beer, delicious hot chicken wings and drumsticks, and excellent pizza and to watch games on TV. Great pizza and great prices and a nice, clean place. Happy hour is every day from 3-6, when you can get buffalo wings or a slice of pizza for 3.99 or a salad or glass of red wine for 3.49, or a beer, or glass of wine, or garlic knot bread. Great deals, great prices, and free sports watching. A good variety of salads too.
I always have my doubts when I see places labeled as NY pizza. I lived in Manhattan and Brooklyn growing up, the Mecca of real pizza. This might just be the finest version of pizza I've had in CA. This truly was an excellent example of NY pizza. The crust was thin and crisp. The sauce was just enough. The cheese was perfect. I had pepperoni on one half, hand made Italian sliced meatball on the other. Garlic knots were bite sized for more flavor for the surface area. Garlic fries were amazing with marinara sauce on the side. I really couldn't have been more impressed with this unassuming and dare I say sterile looking shop. Bravo. Will return Everytime I'm in the area.